As We Travel – Travel Videos & Travel Blog

Do You Still Trust Government Travel Warnings?

Sofia December 10, 2010 Travel Advice 18 Comments

Perhaps you’ve heard the story of Peter and the Wolf? It’s an old fairytale about Peter who always lies and lies – telling people that a wolf is coming – which never happens. So when the wolf finally does come, nobody believes him anymore.

Do You Still Trust Government Travel Warnings?   rtw travel advice    wolf violent protests truth tourists tourist warning Thailand terrorist threat proportion peter and the wolf last time India governments fairytale Europe deaf ears charter flights blogsherpa bloggers Bangkok Bali The outline of the story is that if you warn people about something that isn’t there, eventually they’ll stop listening or trusting you.

You see a similar pattern in the media today as well. I don’t mean to get politically involved, but I’m curious to know your thoughts of the matter.

Does the media sometimes exaggerate what is going on, and steer people away from traveling to countries when they don’t really have to?

Whatever it is, it sure seems like people have stopped listening, and look for other ways to find out the truth.

This became very clear to me a few months ago when the media talked a lot about the violent protests in Thailand. The governments were strongly advising people to stay away from there, but the warnings seemed to fall on deaf ears.

The tourists didn’t listen and continued to travel there even though their government advised them not to.

Do You Still Trust Government Travel Warnings?   rtw travel advice    wolf violent protests truth tourists tourist warning Thailand terrorist threat proportion peter and the wolf last time India governments fairytale Europe deaf ears charter flights blogsherpa bloggers Bangkok Bali At the same time I read articles from bloggers who were in Bangkok at the time, and according to them the protests didn’t seem to have bothered them too much, and that the media had just blown it out of proportion.

I can relate to it myself.

Last time I went to India there was a “massive” terrorist threat over the places we were visiting.

Since we booked our tickets independently, we had no idea about this until we were already there.

We thought it was a bit strange that we were the only tourists around, but found out that all charter flights had been canceled (pretty sweet for us :p).

Apart from that the streets were empty of tourists, and our favorite night market was closed, we saw no difference what so ever.

Do You Still Trust Government Travel Warnings?   rtw travel advice    wolf violent protests truth tourists tourist warning Thailand terrorist threat proportion peter and the wolf last time India governments fairytale Europe deaf ears charter flights blogsherpa bloggers Bangkok Bali Same thing happened when we went to Bali. The government warned people against going there due to kidnapping risks and such things.

I felt more safe there than anywhere else in the world.

However, I’m still not quite sure what to think when I hear these warnings.

What do you think? Have you experienced similar things? Are all these travel warning really necessary?

( photo credits: best_photoswimparallel )

  • http://twitter.com/jerickp Jerick Parrone

    It won’t stop me from travelling & exploring but most likely I’ll do it with some caution.

    • http://108.167.164.229/~wwwaswet Sofia

      Thanks for sharing your opinion, I agree, keep traveling but always do it with a little caution.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Do You Still Trust Government Travel Warnings? – As We Travel – Around The World Travel Blog -- Topsy.com

  • http://twitter.com/backpackingww Matt Hope

    I think it’s important to take most of the warnings with a grain of salt. I feel like heading to the lonely planet forums or something similar is a better way to get a grasp of the real situation in any given area. Most of the time people will tell you straight up where you should or shouldn’t go.

    • http://108.167.164.229/~wwwaswet Sofia

      Travel forums can really be a savior! Honest opinions from travelers who are there are usually the most accurate ones. Thanks for sharing your tip.

  • http://www.zefwebdesign.co.uk Jozef Maxted

    Yeah i think you may be right, it can scare you off unnecessarily. When we were planning our trip there was a military coup in Ecuador and the Goverment advised against travelling there, so we altered our plans to avoid Ecuador.

    Since then I have read loads of blogs and forums where people said the whole thing just blow over in a couple of days and its fine.

    Its annoying, but I supoose what you do depends on whether you want ot take the risk of booking your tickets only to have to cancell the trip later.

    • http://108.167.164.229/~wwwaswet/ As We Travel

      Things like that are annoying, sometimes if you’re unsure it’s better to be safe than sorry, and just focus on enjoying the rest of the trip.

  • http://twitter.com/mystical_moon - Unknown -

    Government warnings are a good starting point for people to read before they travel in my opinion. However, the government will always address issues on the worst possible outcome to cover their own back.

    Which is why they should be read with an open mind and always taken with a pinch of salt.

    The best advice you will get is from other travellers within the area, people should utilize all advice before making judgements about travel based on soley government fuelled fear.

  • http://twitter.com/traveldudes Melvin

    I remember when we planned a trip to Indochina and the bird flu broke out. Many people canceled their trips and because of that & the whole media bla bla, we were really in thoughts… not me, but the others! ;-)

    In the end we made the trip & it was excellent. I’ve eaten so much chicken & it was delicious!

    If I seem a bit weird here & there… maybe because of that trip? LOL

    • http://108.167.164.229/~wwwaswet/ As We Travel

      haha ok that explains it ;P!
      Glad you decided to make the trip and had a great time!

  • http://waywardtraveller.com/ Annie

    I think that advice about taking the warnings with a pinch of salt is very good. I also think that the only reason I would actually change my plans or avoid a place is if there were actual reports of these things going on at the time, real situations and stories.

    For the most part our fears are just fed by the media and they can put whatever they want to out there. Usually it’s not the complete truth and it’s meant to save their own asses, not protect ours.

    Take for example Earl over at http://www.wanderingearl.com who has been traveling the Middle East and being absolutely celebrated by the people for coming to see them and being American. The media would tell us it’s not safe to go there and not to, thankfully Earl didn’t listen and now he has amazing TRUE stories to share with the rest of us and encourage us!

    The other was the incident this year with government warnings against traveling in the major touristed cities of Europe because they were terrorists targets. Of course, this could have been a real threat but thankfully it didn’t seem to stop many people. It seemed a bit off to me that terrorists would target Americans in European cities, running the risk of killing more Europeans than Americans realistically. This is what the warning stated anyway, and there were no reports of any attacks so I wouldn’t have suggested anyone stop traveling.

    I apologize if this comment runs a little off topic but I thought it was relevant! Great post Sofia!

  • http://www.buenosaireslocaltours.com Jonathan Evans

    I don’t think the question is “Do you still trust…?”, but “Have you ever trusted…?”. Obviously security gets more coverage these days so is more on our minds but I don’t think the situation has fundamentally changed. Government security advice is a cover-all and can never apply to one person’s circumstances, or to one place.

    There is some truth behind the warnings, but as always the individual needs to do some thinking for themselves. Now if I could just get my mum to realise that….

  • http://wherespoople.com Jack and Jill Travel The World

    If I listen to government travel warning too closely, I’d never get to go home (I’m from Indonesia). For other countries, I always check with friends who live there, or travel forums to hear the news from the ground.

    Then again, I’m always more concerned about offending the local laws than anything else. For example, we’re making a trip to Singapore and gotta make sure we’re leaving our packs of gum behind :p

    • http://108.167.164.229/~wwwaswet Sofia

      Friends and forums are the best way to get closest to the truth. Haha, yes leave the gum at home! I heard that the fine is something between 500 to 1000 US dollars for “first time offenders”!

  • http://www.baconismagic.ca Ayngelina

    You know what is ridiculous. In Latin America Colombia and Mexico are on the US list but Venezuela is not. It’s complete garbage.

  • http://twitter.com/saintexp Saint Expedite

    The US State Department has people in the trouble spots, and I would be inclined to take their advice seriously. http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/tw/tw_1764.html

    I am less inclined to rely on anecdotal reports. As noted in the Harpers magazine index last May, the violent crime rate in America fell 4.4% in 2009, yet 4 out of 5 people believe crime went up last year. Individual reports (whether pro or con) often lack perspective.

    • http://twitter.com/mystical_moon - Unknown -

      @Saint Expedite. Don’t forget, if any country becomes to dangerous, the first ones to be pulled out are expats. If they people in the trouble spots, then it can’t be THAT dangerous, because they wouldn’t run the risk.

  • http://fastforwardacademy.com/index-page-continuing-professional-education-enrolled-agent.htm enrolled agent cpe

    The media’s tendency to exaggerate some news can greatly affect a country’s tourism industry. Of course there’s always this warning of possible terror attacks in several countries in south East Asia but it doesn’t stop people from traveling. I think they should be more careful in choosing the words to describe a situation. But a traveler should also take this things into consideration.